Anarchism and hunting.
I’ve given this a lot of thought now, so hear me out: The traditional Christian hegemony teaches that the plants and animals of the earth are here for us to exploit, and as a society, we do so terrifically.
We are also taught that we are somehow special, that we have a monopoly on consciousness. I’ve come to realize that consciousness isn’t anything but a human construct to rationalize the supposed disconnect in between our physical and mental or spiritual selves according to religious thought. There is actually only one entity, and it’s just a living bag of water and chemistry designed to effectively propagate DNA.
But we have feelings, right? So it wouldn’t be right to subject a human being to unnecessary suffering. Well, as we don’t have a monopoly on being alive, and therefore don’t have a monopoly on consciousness, it stands to reason that a cow probably doesn’t enjoy the slaughterhouse any more than a death row inmate. Pigs definitely have feelings, and like dogs can make great pets and companions. So, we don’t hold the monopoly on feelings either.
So where do we draw the line? If we don’t have a monopoly on feelings or consciousness, do we draw scientific boundaries such as the complexity of an animal’s nervous system to determine the ethics of its consumption? There is still some natural imperative behind the foods we eat, just as there is a natural imperative for the fox to hunt the rabbit.
We can’t all opt out of the corporate farming of meats entirely and become a nation of hunter-gatherers, but we can take steps to increase our self-reliance and contribute less to corporations that treat organisms as means to a bottom line.
In short, I believe eating meat is ethical, and tasty, and as an omnivorous species, important to our health. But I know that when I hunt or fish for wild animals, that animal has had as fair a shot at whatever that animal’s idea of happiness as could be expected of it. It’s not going to be factory farmed in a pen, or live in its own shit, or get fed food provided by the lowest bidder. I could ensure that the animals I hunt are taken humanely, and experience the humility of a person who has to take the steps between taking an animal and turning it into something you eat, instead of going to the corporate supermarket and skipping all the steps from something that lived to something that exists in your mind only as an ingredient.
Gabe S.
